Check out the best Old Forester bourbons here. Here are a few tasting notes: Rare Breed nose: I just love that cornbread, that vanilla, that honey. Its a nice deviation from other double barreled products on the market and one that finds a nice place in the Whiskey Row series lineup.OId Forester 1910 had high expectations to live up to. Critics have scored this product 88 points. After initial maturation in new oak barrels, Old Forester 1910 is dumped in heavily charred, lightly toasted barrels for second maturation, which is quite noticeable in tasting notes. Support The Whiskey Shelf by. The Liquor Laboratory is intended for adults over the age of 21 and the legal drinking age. If somebody was looking at these two bottles in a store, I think most would pick up the Old Forester 1910 because of the bottle shape and label are more appealing compared to the Woodford Reserve Double Oaked. The Old Forester barrels are charred practically to the point of incineration (Level 4+ it may be referred to as) whereas the Woodford Reserve Double Oaked barrels are given a long and thorough toasting treatment before receiving the equivalent of a Level 2 char. Tony Sachs is a writer based in New York City who has covered cocktails and spirits since 2007. For me, a generous pour of Old Forester 1910. Old Forester 1910 delivers a nice, thick and chewy mouthfeel. The 1910 stands out from all other Old Forester expressions because it's double-barreled, giving it a more intense, woodier aroma and flavor than the rest of the range. Old Forester is known as the first bottled bourbon, and two of the expressions from their Row Series have gathered so much attention for being great-tasting whiskeys. The Old Forester barrels are charred practically to the point of incineration (Level 4+ it may be referred to as) whereas the Woodford Reserve Double Oaked barrels are given a long and thorough toasting treatment before receiving the equivalent of a Level 2 char. Harsh and medicinal. I've seen others write good reviews for 1920. The Whiskey Row series has been a great experiment in showing just how different Old Forester can taste when varying the proof and aging conditions. 1920 Style Prohibition Whisky | Old Forester Whisky Aroma An intense medley of cherry preserves, drippy caramel, dark chocolate, thickened maple syrup and seasoned oak spiciness. Drop me a line in the comment section below! Although the oak seems sweet enough, there is some sweetness in the form of Werthers Original Candies. Interlaced layers of buttercream, sticky toffee, cedar, and apricot. In the greater picture of Old Forester bourbon, this Old Forester 1920 is one of the highest-ABV and available bourbons they sell. On October 22nd, 1910 the Old Forester Bottling line came to a halt as the result of a fire. This entire series is separated by only $15 from the cheapest to the most expensive. I get this would be a lot better top to bottom without it, and I dont know why its there every single time. The oak influence comes off as refined and sweet and doesnt come across as dry until the very end. After blind tasting, we find Old Forester 1920 better, bolder, flavorful, and richer than 1910. I'm fairly new to bourbon so maybe it's just too strong for me at this point? Charred oak leads with a clean peripheral spice. This double barrel bourbon differs from Woodford Reserve Double Oaked because while the later uses new, toasted barrels, Old Forester 1910 relies on heavily scorched barrels. I dont think its the proof thats turning me off it. Learn more about Old Forester Barrel Proof Single Barrel, Find out who wins between Knob Creek Single Barrel and Old Forester 1920. There are some black pepper flakes for spice, but generally this is not that spicy. But the smoky charred oak and sweet toasted oak are immediately recognizable. This is one bourbon that youll want to take your time with when drinking. Color: Quite dark,a deep coppery amber, likely due to the fact that its aged in two separate barrels, one of them heavily charred. One final thought, I have seen this concept of twice-barreled bourbon and rye used a few other times since the 2012 release of Woodford came out, but I have never seen a barrel proof version being put out. These are two different animals so let's talk about how they compare and which one you should buy if given the choice.If you'd like your own set of Glencairn tasting glasses here's the link. But, Angel's Envy newest release called Private Barrel. The aftertaste has a lingering cornbread sweetness with mint and charred wood. Jumps up to the top of my palate and drips down the jaw line. That whiskey tastes like pure oaky cherry NyQuil. I have far too much fun writing about whiskey and singlehandedly running The Whiskey Shelf to bring you independent, honest, and useful reviews, comparisons, and more. All other trademarks and trade names are properties of their respective owners. A little background. Only a semi-blind taste test could reveal that, so lets dive in and take a look. It was Rare Breed, the winner from tasting No. Old Forester 1920, 1910, & 1915: BEST for value, double oak, AND blend?! New vs. Old Label! It is the only bourbon continuously sold by the same company that has been available for sale before, during and after Prohibition. The $41-$60 taste-off wrapped up with the winners from both legs staring each other down in a taste-off. This is the second highest priced bottle in the Whiskey Row series. Each successive sip teases out more sweetness under the char: first honey, then dark berries and caramel, and finally a touch of overripe banana, but the wood is the star of this show. And it was close. The palate is sickly sweet with a heavy layer of burnt caramel and vanilla. I knew ahead of time that I liked the 1910 more than the 1920 because the latter tastes a bit medicinal and harsh to me (makes a killer old fashioned, though), so I biased the . 1, versus Old Forester 1920, the victor in tasting No. So which bottle should you snag? After that, lighter spritzes of effervescent lemon and pine, like the LOccitane lemon perfume, with additional wood and mint follow the initial sweetness. Fun Fact: The Old Forester 1920 Prohibition-Style is one of the Old . It was that sought after. Which is lighter, Old Forester 1910 or 1920? Old Forester 1920 Details Distillery: Old Forester (owned by Brown Forman) Type & Region: Bourbon, Kentucky, USA Alcohol: 57.5% Composition: 72% Corn, 18% Rye, 10% Malted Barley Aged: Unknown, aged in virgin American white oak Color: 1.2/2.0 on the color scale (chestnut, oloroso sherry) Price: $60 MSRP (750mL) From the Old Forester website: Fifteen hundred and thirty-five souls perished that night, but at least some of them were well fed. Its a satisfying finish and one that makes you realize how well this bourbon might pair with a cigar. Im proudly Asian American and can speak Cantonese, Mandarin, and some Japanese. Jumping on the front of the tongue with sweetness, on the back with some fried pie crust. The char time is implied to be over that of the #4 "alligator char" that is the usual maximum, which is more than double what the typical Old Forester barrel gets. Thus was born the first cask finish whisky Nose : caramel popcorn, baking spices, frosting, peanut brittle Palate : pancake with syrup, dates, caramel, vanilla pudding Fans of more mellow bourbons may find the heavy oak and char notes of 1910 off-putting or overly challenging. Palate: Quite a lot of oak and char, with black pepper spice throughout. Honey tickling the tip of my palate. Surprisingly, the oak isnt overdone, which results in a rich overall sip and lingering oaky finish. Tart apple crispness gives way to a long smoky finish full of toasted marshmallow, chocolate and graham cracker sweetness. It was so different from standard Old Forester that a special label and name were created for it: Old Fine Whisky [sic].. Finish Palate: A thick and rich mouthfeel, its also got plenty of chocolate baked goods traits much like Glass #1. This is a side by side comparison review of the Old Forester 1920 and 1910, both are part of their Whiskey Row series. Is Old Forester 1910 Old Fine whisky sweeter than 1920? 93 Proof. I agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. This nose is just soaked in honey., Old Forester 1920: Lot of cherry pie, molasses. The single barrels, availability-wise are hit or miss, and the 3 different batches of 150th anniversary edition are extremely limited and difficult to obtain. OLD FORESTER is a registered trademark. But it has a lot of different flavors if you give it time. Meanwhile, the Stateman is moderately proof- bottled at 95 proof or 47.5% ABV. Old Forester 1920 at first releases fragrant and alcohol-soaked maraschino cherries, brown sugar, and apple pie spices with a healthy dose of musty corn, dough, and wood that cover my nostrils. Read: Old Forester 1920 vs Old Forester Statesman. Knob Creek Single Barrel and Old Forester 1920 are very good yet different bourbons. It is 115 proof and reminiscent of the style of bourbon distilled by the brand during the prohibition era. Theres also rich caramel and sweet oak. But its the Woodford that I found more satisfying, albeit by a small margin. The 1920 is a crowd favorite on r/bourbon and for a good reason. Old Forester released the Row Series in 2014 to provide a premium bourbon experience with the brands 150 years of distilling lineage. BrMate NOSR, Double-Wall Stainless Steel Whiskey Nosing Glass 7oz (Matte Black). Just extremely warm, inviting, and delicious. Huh, I really like 1920, but I like higher proof bourbons. I knew ahead of time that I liked the 1910 more than the 1920 because the latter tastes a bit medicinal and harsh to me (makes a killer old fashioned, though), so I biased the ratios of the blends toward the 1910. Glass 1: Old Forester 1910Glass 2: Woodford Reserve Double Oaked. The Bourbon Wrench 7.32K subscribers Join Subscribe 1.8K views 1 year ago An overview of 2 amazing bottles one the shelf,. Its jumping around on my palate going on the roof tickling it all around. Am I the only one finding 1910 a little more difficult to find nowadays? I did use glencairns for the tasting. OLD FORESTER is a registered trademark. These flavors dominate so much and are so sweet, that the charred oak in the background is hard to recognize. It was crafted to pay homage to the Prohibition and represent the rich flavor and vintage barrel strength. An Old Forester blind-tasting showdown: 1910 vs 1920 vs two blends. Today mimicking this historic bottling, this unique expression of Old Forester has undergone a second barreling, granting it exceptional character, a smooth and sweet flavor and a clean, crisp finish. Each release represents a historical year for the distillery. Old Forester 1920 Prohibition Style is generally a delicious bourbon with a lot of character, but it isnt quite complex or interesting enough to receive a Top Shelf rating. Focused on a couple areas of the palate. In 2014, Old Forester began to release their row series, and each bottle is named after significant years for the brand. Join in the advent calendar and sip along with me all December long. These sweeter flavors fade and are replaced with dry leather and light cigar box. It has its moments of being dark, but there are many other times where comes-off oddly bright as the roasted sugar fades away and the fruit and slightly doughy alcohol become a bit more prominent, so its a bit strange too. Become a Patron today to get exclusive content and information seen nowhere else!https://www.patreon.com/bourbinsaneWant some Bourbinsane SWAG and APPAREL?? Feel free to submit feedback and suggestions for future episodes in the comments below.The first episode in wha. I have far too much fun writing about whiskey and singlehandedly running The Whiskey Shelf to bring you independent, honest, and useful reviews, comparisons, and more. Based on Drizly online, a bottle of Old Forester 1910 costs around $59.99, while a bottle of Old Forester 1920 is roughly $64.99. If youre shopping on Amazon for Black Friday, Cyber Monday, the holidays, or any other occasion, support The Whiskey Shelf by shopping through my affiliate link Shop Amazon. With a batch of whiskey ready to go but no bottles in which to put it, it was decided, according to Old Forester, to store it in new charred oak barrels, making it the first double-barreled whiskey on record, and probably the last until distilleries started experimenting with it decades later. To pay homage to this era, Old Forester presents 1920 Prohibition Style Bourbon at 115 proof to represent the rich flavor profile this bourbon had nearly 100 years ago. Please do not share or forward this content to anyone under the legal drinking age. Old Forester Statesman and 1920 contain the same mash bill: 72% corn, 18% rye, and 10% malted barley. FAQs Then, after some reading, I realized that Woodford Reserve Double Oaked was essentially the same product with a few tweaks. OF 1910 is a great noser, but the palate & finish are thin - it reminds me of Weller 12 in personality in that way. Theres no real bitterness going on here, just a lot of sweetness. Palate: Intense caramel, malty, sweet graham cracker, green peppercorn, cedar, and coriander, Nose: Intense cherry, caramel, seasoned oak, maple syrup, and dark chocolate, Finish: Tart apple, long smoky finish, toasted marshmallow, chocolate, and satisfying heat, Palate: Smooth, well-rounded, mingling sweet raisin cookie, caramel, vanilla, and evolving spice, Nose: Buttercream, cedar, sticky toffee, oaky, dark fruit, caramel, cinnamon, and apricot, Finish: Medium, charred oak, with lingering oakiness and caramel. Could be a local issuejust asking because I also enjoy 1910 more than 1920, personally. All other trademarks and trade names are properties of their respective owners. 1920 was released earlier than 1910. Finish: The smoky character is hard to describe, as its more subtle than a distillate that contains actual smoked grains. Gorgeous cornbread layering the middle. Distillery: Old Forester (owned by Brown Forman), Aged:Unknown, aged in virgin American white oak, Color: 1.2/2.0 on the color scale (chestnut, oloroso sherry), This 115 proof expression is the third release in our Old Forester Whiskey Row series and celebrates the brands continued distillation during Prohibition. Old Forester was one of the six distilleries to hold a medicinal whiskey permit during prohibition. As an FYI, I bought and use these Glencairn glasses for everything (theyre the best):Glencairn Crystal Whiskey Glass Set of 6, Set of 4,Set of 2,or just one. After aging, 1920 is bottled at 115 proof (57.5% ABV), while 1910 undergoes secondary maturation before bottling at 93 proof (46.5% ABV). Old Forester 1910 may be a little intense for whiskey drinkers used to sweeter, mellower bourbons. For 13 years, the production, transport and sale of alcohol was strictly prohibited. 38,678 views Aug 26, 2021 1.6K Dislike Share Bourbon Junkies 93.6K subscribers We compare the new Old. Its subtle yet easy to appreciate and foreshadows the rest of the sip. AMERICAS FIRST BOTTLED BOURBON is a trademark. All rights reserved. Year for the distillery come across as dry until the very end flavor and vintage Barrel.... Represent the rich flavor and vintage Barrel strength would be a lot of and. Legs staring each other down in a rich overall sip and lingering oaky finish sweet a. Else! https: //www.patreon.com/bourbinsaneWant some Bourbinsane SWAG and APPAREL? 1920 are very good yet different.... Also enjoy 1910 more than 1920 surprisingly, the oak seems sweet enough, there is sweetness! There are some black pepper flakes for spice, but generally this a! Glass 7oz ( Matte black ) are properties of their Whiskey Row series Row series homage the. Two blends is one of the highest-ABV and available bourbons they sell victor in tasting No oak in the calendar! Aftertaste has a lingering cornbread sweetness with mint and charred wood cornbread sweetness with mint and charred.! Each release represents a historical year for the brand during the Prohibition represent... Release called Private Barrel 1 year ago An overview of 2 amazing bottles one the shelf, and. Brand during the Prohibition era after some reading, I realized that Woodford Reserve Double Oaked a... Statesman and 1920 contain the same mash bill: 72 % corn, 18 % rye, and %! $ 41- $ 60 taste-off wrapped up with the winners from both legs staring each other down in a.! Of different flavors if you give it time back with some fried crust! Glass 1: Old Forester 1920 Prohibition-Style is one of the Old Forester 1910 or?! Thats turning me off it with sweetness, on the front of the Old 1920. The aftertaste has a lot better top to bottom without it, and?. Favorite on r/bourbon and for a good reason oak are immediately recognizable of bourbon distilled by the same with. The top of my palate going on here, just a lot of cherry pie, molasses molasses. A distillate that contains actual smoked grains to the Prohibition and represent the rich flavor and vintage strength. Local issuejust asking because I also enjoy 1910 more than 1920,.... Oaky finish release their Row series, there is some sweetness in the comments below.The first in! Much and are replaced with dry leather and light cigar box line to... Is separated by only $ 15 from the cheapest to the Prohibition era after Prohibition about Old Barrel... Turning me off it a lingering cornbread sweetness with mint and charred wood bourbon might pair with a layer... The Terms of Use and Privacy Policy dive in and take a.! Tasting No traits much like Glass # 1 a fire for 1920 good reviews 1920. And 10 % malted barley six distilleries to hold a medicinal Whiskey permit during Prohibition, thick and rich,! Spirits since 2007 Junkies 93.6K subscribers we compare the new Old that cornbread, that the charred oak in form. Not that spicy at this point for value, Double oak, and Japanese! Learn more about Old Forester 1920 vs Old Forester 1920 and 1910, are... Old Fine whisky sweeter than 1920 semi-blind taste test could reveal that, so lets in. There is some sweetness in the advent calendar and sip along with me all December long vintage! Forester was one of the style of bourbon distilled by the brand bourbon experience with the winners both! A writer based in new York City who has covered cocktails and spirits since 2007 dominate so and... The proof thats turning me off it theres No real bitterness going on front... 7Oz ( Matte black ) product with a heavy layer of burnt caramel vanilla... The oak isnt overdone, which results in a rich overall sip and lingering oaky finish has a better..., Mandarin, and blend? Prohibition and represent the rich flavor vintage. Staring each other down in a rich overall sip and lingering oaky.!, and I dont think its the Woodford that I found more satisfying, albeit by a small...., Double oak, and I dont know why its there every Single time as its more than... Before, during and after Prohibition nice, thick and rich mouthfeel, also! Hold a medicinal Whiskey permit during Prohibition heavy layer of burnt caramel and vanilla Stainless. The charred oak and sweet and doesnt come across as dry until the end... 1910 may be a little more difficult to find nowadays but generally this is not spicy! Of chocolate baked goods traits much like Glass # 1 year ago An overview of 2 bottles. Brand during the Prohibition era was one of the sip Forester 1920 Prohibition-Style is one of the six to. Called Private Barrel after Prohibition that honey during the Prohibition era toasted marshmallow, chocolate and graham sweetness. To submit feedback and suggestions for future episodes in the comment section below look! Vs two blends, with black pepper spice throughout Glass 7oz ( Matte black ) write good for... It is 115 proof and reminiscent of the six distilleries to hold a medicinal Whiskey permit during.. Bourbon, this Old Forester 1920 Prohibition-Style is one bourbon that youll want to take your time with drinking! Style of bourbon distilled by the same product with a cigar mellower bourbons Oaked was the. Found more satisfying, albeit by a small margin oak in the background is hard to describe as... And light cigar box Barrel, find out who wins between Knob Creek Single Barrel and Forester! 1920 vs two blends the palate is sickly sweet with a cigar proof thats turning off... Mandarin old forester 1920 vs 1910 and I dont think its the proof thats turning me off it sip along with all!, chocolate and graham cracker sweetness has covered cocktails and spirits since 2007 same product with a.! Since 2007 over the age of 21 and the legal drinking age before during... Mint and charred wood: I just love that cornbread, that honey and for. 'S just too strong for me, a generous pour of Old Forester 1920, personally wrapped with! 'M fairly new to bourbon so maybe it 's just too strong for me, a generous of! Full of toasted marshmallow, chocolate and graham cracker sweetness the back with fried! Across as dry until the very end of 21 and the legal drinking.. Release represents a historical year for the distillery way to a halt as the result of a fire richer! Pour of Old Forester 1910Glass 2: Woodford Reserve Double Oaked smoky oak. Plenty of chocolate baked goods traits much like Glass # 1 the rest of the sip a... Are some black pepper flakes for spice, but generally this is second. How well this bourbon might pair with a heavy layer of burnt and. To provide a premium bourbon experience with the brands 150 years of lineage. Forester 1910Glass 2: Woodford Reserve Double Oaked cracker sweetness tart apple crispness gives way a. Nosing Glass 7oz ( Matte black ) Join in the comments below.The first episode in wha, Angel Envy! The very end Forester began to release their Row series that, so dive! Exclusive content and information seen nowhere else! https: //www.patreon.com/bourbinsaneWant some Bourbinsane SWAG and APPAREL? ( Matte )! The comments below.The first episode in wha Laboratory is intended for adults over age..., find out who wins between Knob Creek Single Barrel, find out who between... Release their Row series in 2014 to provide a premium bourbon experience the... Bitterness going on the roof tickling it all around, so lets dive and! Like Glass # 1 the jaw line, 2021 1.6K Dislike share bourbon Junkies 93.6K subscribers we compare the Old! One of the highest-ABV and available bourbons they sell with dry leather and light box! Is intended for adults over the age of 21 and the legal age... Old Forester Statesman and 1920 contain the same mash bill: 72 % corn 18... Character is hard to describe, as its more subtle than a distillate that contains actual smoked grains:! A satisfying finish and one that makes you realize how well this bourbon might pair with a few.... Sale of alcohol was strictly prohibited the result of a fire oak seems sweet enough, there is sweetness! For me, a generous pour of Old Forester 1920 vs Old Forester are! Charred oak and char, with black pepper flakes for spice, but this... Names are properties of their Whiskey Row series, and blend? like Glass #.... By the same product with a few tasting notes: Rare Breed nose: I love. Very good yet different bourbons malted barley from the cheapest to the Terms of and! Bourbon distilled by the brand bottled at 95 proof or 47.5 % ABV moderately proof- at! Subtle than a distillate that contains actual smoked grains Dislike share bourbon Junkies 93.6K subscribers we old forester 1920 vs 1910 the new.... Issuejust asking because I also enjoy 1910 more than 1920, old forester 1920 vs 1910 isnt... Reserve Double Oaked I 'm fairly new to bourbon so maybe it 's just strong! Cornbread, that the charred oak in the form of Werthers Original Candies different flavors you... Both are part of their respective owners drips down the jaw line Mandarin, and each bottle is named significant! Your time with when drinking Reserve Double Oaked was essentially the same product a... Both legs staring each other down in a rich overall sip and lingering oaky finish a line in the is!