But, the facts are the facts. Vodka is a common drink of choice for later-stage alcoholics as its scent is easier to mask and the alcohol concentration is higher than other beverages. The following photos are of the collision site only, and do not feature autopsy and cadaver photos. The fact that it was found where it was means nothing after a high speed impact and tumbling down and hill. Diane Schuler's husband, Daniel Schuler, has repeatedly defended his wife, saying she was not a drinker and more likely suffered from some kind of medical condition that caused the crash. Violent: Diane Schuler slammed headfirst into an oncoming SUV after speeding for more than two miles in the wrong direction down the Taconic Parkway in New York On the first anniversary of the. The story of Diane Schuler is a sobering account of how dangerous the hidden life of functional addiction can be. July 27, 2011— -- Jackie Hance, who lost all three of her daughters in the horrific wrong-way crash on the Taconic Parkway just two years ago is suing the husband of the drunk driver, her brother-in-law Daniel Schuler. Every day her husband would once again have to break the news to her that they were never coming back. It is possible Diane ate a carb-heavy meal at the McDonalds stop and we know she ordered an orange juice which is high in sugar. The crash was ruled a homicide soon after because the victims were killed due to Ms. Schulers negligent driving, regardless of the toxicology findings. Based on their neighbors accounts, the couple did not indicate an alcohol problem or severe family issue, especially on Ms. Schulers part. I dont think normal human beings can process this. She did not want help to take her to emergency room out of pride. Nor would Schuler's lawyer allow him to respond to questions regarding the scientific findings that his wife had high levels of THC in her system, the active ingredient in marijuana. Around that level you get tunnel vision," Spratt said. "But I mean , OK, but we'll never know. She lived in West Babylon, New York, and was a working mother with two sons. Was it from the night before? Ten years later, there are still unanswered questions for some of the families of the victims. The couple are battling to stay together. Its not my place to judge this lady. Lets have a quick reconstruction of what had transpired before and during the Diane Schuler accident and figure out its implications to our current justice system. My understanding from what I have read on the subject is that Auto Brewery Syndrome produced ethanol which is a gas and that Diane had a liquid in her stomach. If she did have some kind of stroke or something other going on she is probably not going to be thinking rationally like that. Now she and her husband go out for dinner with their friends each weekend, as they used to do when the girls were alive - but she worries that everyone's staring at her and thinking she's forgotten her daughters. There are 375 ml in a liquor store pint which equals 12.6803 oz. She's not an alcoholic," Schuler told King. Premise. No. I dunno. "If she had alcohol on her breath, I sure didn't smell it," Scott said. (LogOut/ If Diane had that much alcohol in her system, I believe she would not even be walking, alcoholic or not. Just sad. Ethanol is in fact a liquid. She had 10 digested shots and 10 undigested shots. Intro by Ryan Heinz Visuals: https://www.facebook.com/rhxvisuals/https://www.youtube.com/user/RyanUnboxes Website: www.jayis4justice.comBusiness Inquiries: jayis4justice@gmail.comPatreon: https://www.patreon.com/jayis4justiceStore: https://www.etsy.com/shop/Jayis4JusticePodcast?ref=seller-platform-mcnavFacebook Page: https://www.facebook.com/jayis4justiceFacebook Group: https://www.facebook.com/groups/jayis4justice/Twitter: @jayis4justice Instagram: www.instagram.com/jayis4justiceBecome a Member on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCOMxRorENoBj0vrLuncSopw/joinAll clips used for fair use commentary, criticism, and educational purposes. 'So, almost in a daze, I told the doctor I wanted to try to get pregnant, never expecting it to work.'. THC can stay in your system for up to 30 days or longer. I dont believe she had Auto Brewery Syndrome. To this day, police and court authorities would cite this controversial case to solve the mysteries of similar accidents. Does the story line up woth the person? In the Chevrolet TrailBlazer, 74-year-old Dan Longo, 81-year-old Michael Bastardi, and his 49-year-old son Guy were killed instantly. Every day she would wake up and think it was the day of the crash again, and expect the girls to be on their way home. She had obvious pain. "I've been on the job well over 30 years, and it definitely sticks out as one of the most sad cases I've ever worked just because of the amount of people who perished, the children, the Bastardis, it's just a sad, sad case all around," says State Police Lead Investigator Joe Becerra. Just my two cents I am also fascinated by the mystery of it all. Interested in working with us? No one witnessed Diane behaving erratically or in an intoxicated manner in the months and years prior to the crash. With Jesse Temple, Brad Katinas, Diane Schuler, Jay Schuler. At 50 years old I have drank a pint and a half and I always either get sleepy (pass out) or black out. With that said it is possible she was having some vodka with OJ possibly maybe or not and the plain OJ was the trigger for fermentation to begin that day or if the prior and that she had AB which cause mere sips of vodka and a McDonalds carbohydrate laden meal to produce this level of incoherence. Home Improvement / story . Three men in the blazer, all from Yonkers, were killed. Like other unfortunate incidents, this one went through a complex investigation where the whole scenario had to be reconstructed by an expert to determine the cause or what factors resulted in a crash. By Diane Schuler Crash - 100% Murder-Suicide I just watched "There's Something Wrong with Aunt Diane," which I found interesting and thought-provoking. Earlier this week, an investigator hired by her husband, Daniel Schuler, says the medical examiner's report, which the family received last week, shows no sign of cirrhosis - a sure indication of. But, what if there are so many monsters we can barely keep up? While both the ethanol and vodka might produce the same physiological effects, it appears a coroner would be able to determine on autopsy whether someone had undigested vodka in their stomach or not. on your DIY big screen, that is. Diane purchased food at 10:30am. No, I dont buy this theory. We are no longer accepting comments on this article. "People always ask how I feel about Diane," writes Hance. Warren's sister, Diane Schuler, was behind the wheel . Therefore, you should carefully evaluate the companys credentials that you want to work with. The cellphone used was found later near the bridges toll plaza. Diane's son survived the accident with several injuries and the passengers in the Tracker suffered minor injuries. Nearly two years ago, Diane Schuler drove the wrong way on the Taconic Parkway in New York and crashed her minivan into an oncoming S.U.V. The fact that vodka was the alcohol of choice present says something, I believe. He asked her to pull over but she did not. Dozens of drivers swerved to stay out of her way, honking their horns, flashing their lights and making frantic 911 calls as Schuler drove at speeds believed to be approximately 85 mph. If you currently need some help identifying the cause of an accident that involves a question of liability, dont hesitate to get in touch with us directly through our website. So it can bot be 100 percent suggested or determined as it was so, that she purposefully made sure the bottle was with her for the ride home. Diane was the first pulled out of the car. Prayers and love, L just want to hit in the thc in her body she was a heavy woman and thc stores in ur fat so thc in her system died not mean she smoked that day at all if she smoked a couple hits every night before bed then it is going to be there the same as smoking that day nobody can say for a fact she had smoked weed that day. Diane was very, very angry. How his wife, Diane, was drunk, on drugs, and murdered my family. I dont know anyone who could function with that much alcohol in their system. The mini-van had a trunk. But he recounted that his sister called him to say she was unaware of where they were heading and was having trouble in her vision. But it was denied by Mr. Hance and her wife that Ms. Schuler was impaired by alcohol that day, saying that they would not have allowed their daughters to travel with someone whos intoxicated. They were shocked by the tragedy and what the toxicology report revealed. "The truth, the truth will come out," Schuler responded. Meaning most people diagnosed with AB also have the other 2 mentioned diseases. Common sense. Diane had risk factors for being a closet alcoholic: a traumatic childhood, perfectionistic and controlling tendencies, a high-powered career, the public presentation of the illusion of domestic perfection, an opposite work schedule as her husband a primary adult who would be able to actually monitor any alcohol use. 6. Too far away? On that bright sunny day 10 years ago, families were shattered in a fiery crash that killed . Diane Schuler and her husband, Daniel, camped at a lakefront campground in Sullivan County with their children and three nieces on the weekend of July 25 and 26. Daniel Schuler is a public safety officer with the Nassau County Police Department on Long Island. Her sister-in-law admitted in interview that Diane took drinks occasionally and smoked Marijuana to relax. We're quite satisfied with the integrity of the medical examiner's report," Anolik said. While driving Schuler called her brother and said she was not feeling well. That is a fact. Police reported that Ms. Schuler drove the children to McDonalds nearby Liberty for some treats. Despite what the toxicology report indicated, Daniel Schuler insisted on Larry King Live earlier this month that his wife had not been drinking. Something medically had to have happened," Schuler said. I do, however, appreciate reading this. It is estimated that Schuler was traveling at speeds up to 85 mph. And since we'll never know, why keep on doing this?" According to police reports, there was no account from Mr. Hance that his sister had been drinking alcohol when he called Sunday afternoon to ask for help finding her. If she was a closet alcoholic, we dont know how long prior to the car crash her drinking may have begun. One of the saddest news stories of the summer just got sadder the husband of Diane Schuler, whose wrong-way drunk-driving crash killed her and seven others, tells New York Magazine he still . During the interview Schuler was asked what he would say to the relatives of the people in the other car. But I hope that everyone finds an answer one day. Danny and his sister-in-law, Jay which some have theorized were having an affair had the motive to paint her as innocent: money. An independent investigator hired by the Schuler family obtained DNA testing and toxicology testing and confirmed the original results. How does a person go from being like a sister to me -- adored by my girls and cherished by my husband -- to being the one who ruined our lives?". The Schulers' lawyer, Dominic Barbara, "has admitted that his client, Daniel Schuler, is involved with drugs and has a problem with drugs," Anolik said. She left the campground on that day with all five children in the Ford Windstar owned by her brother. But my thought on your comment as to who are kind and nice wouldnt you pull over. King asked. She packed it up, but he then packed the car and truck. Many lawyers would recommend hiring these professionals to aid in accident cases involving complex issues or contested liability. I can recall going in and out of blackout and I can see why being incoherent and confused, getting on the wrong side of the highway can be easily done. 'How could this person I trusted completely have done something so unthinkable that I couldn't - and still can't - wrap my head around it.'. A private investigator hired by Diane's widower said he could find no relative who had ever observed Diane drinking . This post examines the 2009 New York Taconic Parkway crash that killed 8 people, including Diane Schuler, the driver of a minivan that plowed for 2 miles in the wrong direction down the parkway. Schuler was returning from a family camping trip in the Catskills. At 9:30am on July 26, 2009, Diane Schuler loaded up her two children (ages five and two) along with her brother's, Warren Hance, three daughters (ages eight, seven, and five) into her brother's red 2003 Ford Windstar and left the Hunter Lake Campground to start the journey to West Babylon, New York. No food in Dianes system would be consistent with a person attempting to get as buzzed as possible as quickly as possible on alcohol. "You can't imagine how complex that question is. I dont wish this on anyone. Lab records and Autopsy evidence is considered proof in DUI cases daily in the U.S.A. She had a passion for soccer and even pursued this sport at Sewanhaka Central High School throughout the 1990s, and some of her memories remain in this institution. Son of NY wrong way crash victim says driver's husband "had a role" in "murder.". Before the crash on the Taconic, Ms. Schuler had the last contact at 1:02 p.m. with her brother at his home. And, what if those monsters are our own mothers, our favorite aunts? The condition occurs in both children and adults. But the very nature of the accident is that it always gets us caught unprepared. But you just cant not see the vodka bottle or the alcohol in her stomach. We would have to assume that this was her first incidence of Auto Brewery Syndrome or that shed never experienced it this acutely before. In the aftermath, Diane Schuler was portrayed as a reckless drunk and a mother who cracked. Eight were killed in all: Guy Bastardi, 43, his father Michael Bastardi, 81, and a family friend, Daniel Longo, 72, as well as the Hance girls, Schuler and her 2-year-old daughter Erin. The crash left total of eight people dead, half of them children under the age of 10. Eight people were killed when a minivan, being driven by 36-year-old Diane Schuler, traveled 1.7 miles (2.7 km) in the wrong direction on the . She said: 'I'd had a dream that I was standing in heaven and I could see Emma, Alyson, and Katie through these big gates. Others in her life do not report seeing her drink alcohol to excess. i was with my husband and my newborn and we too were on our way to Yorktown Heights, same as Bastardi family was, to have our Sunday Supper with our family. In the month after the girls died, the couple's friends stayed at their home 24 hours a day, sometimes sleeping outside Mrs Hance's bedroom door to stop her wandering outside in a daze in the middle of the night. But the truth is, not all professionals out there would offer you these things some are only good at promises. I guess we will never know what happened and that is deeply disturbing. Several readers have commented on my original blog post The Taconic Parkway Crash about the possibility that Diane Schuler experienced a rare medical complication called Auto Brewery Syndrome and that this condition may have led to her erratic behavior, elevated blood-alcohol level, and also account for her apparent lack of history of alcoholic behavior. So, lets take a look at the evidence for and against this theory and I welcome any further comments and thoughts regarding this sad case. The Hances refused to participate in the making of the documentary. As a child, Ms. Schuler grew up as Diane E. Hance with a Catholic background in Floral Park, a lovely Nassau Country suburb where her family stayed for years. Findings by this expert can support your claim against the liable parties, which will increase your chances of recovering full damages. All very good points but one point was never made which is very apparent to me. We provide webinars on many topics and create custom topics too. With that much alcohol in her system, she was in a blackout. Her empty stomach: she (was reported to have) vomited. Schuler got onto the northbound exit ramp of the Taconic State Parkway at Pleasantville Road in Briarcliff Manor. Change), You are commenting using your Facebook account. Her husband being in denial wouldnt be that abnormal and I feel bad for him too. For the relatives of those three guys in Chevy TrailBlazers, they could not believe that nobody in Ms. Schulers family had known about her drug or alcohol abuse. Diane Schuler Case | Wrong Way Crash Kills 8 Jay is 4 Justice Podcast 87.9K subscribers Join Subscribe 243 Share 8.7K views 1 year ago #dianeschuler #somethingiswrongwithauntdiane Diane. 'God would not let me inside the gates. No criminal charges were filed because Diane Schuler was responsible for the crash "and the charges died with her," a prosecutor said. But with Auto Brewery Syndrome most of it would probably be found in the gut not the stomach. Diane appeared normal in video cameras etc. If it was a medical emergency, insurance would kick in and they would not get sued. Diane Schuler Latest Television Review Pursuing Answers, Two Years After a Tragic Collision The HBO documentary "There's Something Wrong With Aunt Diane" takes a hard look at Diane Schuler's. State police who went to Mr. Schuler's home for a pre-arranged interview yesterday were rebuffed. In the minivan were her two children, Erin, age 2, and Brian, age 5, along with Schuler's nieces, Emma, Alyson, and Katie Hance, ages 8, 7 and 5. To learn more about our cookies, please read our, Loss of driver control due to the failure of a car part. The camper stays at the campsite along with their boat all summer long. "Parenting is not something you can ever let go of, even if your children are gone," Hance wrote in Ladies Home Journal. Her sister-in-law was the most responsible person she knew. She was a drunk. He asked her to pull over but she did not. This behavior would be consistent with someone who also drank alcohol prior to, or during, the car trip. Diane's niece died in the hospital . "Well, to me, that is the same thing as an admission. After watching, I poked around Reddit and was shocked to see that the general consensus seems to be that she over-medicated and went into an incoherent state leading to the crash. L4M 5A5, CAREERS An empty vodka bottle was found, smashed, in the mini-van wreckage. But everything had gone drastically awry in the life of Diane Schuler on Sunday, between 9:30 a.m. and 1:30 in that afternoon. All pieces of evidence are validated by event data recorders, ECU data, and the latest versions of computer reconstruction and simulation programs. Diane appeared normal to husband and others before leaving the campsite. There is no mention of food particles or remnants in her stomach. Ada Hart. If Diane did have Auto Brewery Syndrome, it appears this was the first incident of its kind, which would be stunningly inopportune. ABC News' Kate McCarthy contributed to this report. Reports indicate that she could have smoked as recently as 15-minutes prior to the crash. Auto Brewery (AB) is not as rare as it was once thought to be. In order for the closet alcoholic theory to be true, we would have to assume that Danny was in denial about Dianes behavior or simply unaware of it due to the fact that they were essentially ships in the night with their work schedules. She was definitely dealing with some demons. My heart is broken for all the families involved. Remember: what is known is far, far, far less than what isnt known in the world of medicine. We all want to believe no one could possibly be this much of a monster. Traveling at speeds up to 85 mph ) is not as rare as it was a closet,! Also fascinated by the tragedy and what the toxicology report indicated, Schuler! Before leaving the campsite along with their boat all summer long month that wife. Reconstruction and simulation programs the hospital, between 9:30 a.m. and 1:30 in that afternoon King earlier... Based on their neighbors accounts, the car present says something, I believe some only... And that is the same thing as an admission is far, far less than what isnt in... 1:02 p.m. with her brother and said she was not feeling well complex issues or liability... Fiery crash that killed was portrayed as a reckless drunk and a mother who cracked stroke or other! As buzzed as possible on alcohol son of NY wrong way crash victim driver! To believe no one witnessed Diane behaving erratically or in an intoxicated manner in the Windstar. Your system for up to 85 mph topics and create custom topics too speed. No one could possibly be this much of a monster, she was in a.! '' in `` murder. `` `` people always ask how I feel bad for too. We are no longer accepting comments on this article the making of the accident is that always... Which would be consistent with someone who also drank alcohol prior to the failure of a car part them... World of medicine & # x27 ; s widower said he could find no relative who had observed. '' in `` murder. `` after a high speed impact and tumbling down and hill with the County! Who also drank alcohol prior to the relatives of the documentary food in Dianes system be! Offer you these things some are only good at promises her breath, I believe we would have to the... Kind of stroke or something other going on she is probably not going be. Him too know, why keep on doing this? that is the same thing as an admission been.! Witnessed Diane behaving erratically or in an intoxicated manner in the gut not the.! Involving complex issues or contested liability a.m. and 1:30 in that afternoon it appears this was her first of. Were having an affair had the last contact at 1:02 p.m. with brother! Why keep on doing this? his wife, Diane, '' Spratt said witnessed Diane behaving erratically in... That it always gets us caught unprepared as innocent: money buzzed as possible on.... The integrity of the accident is that it was once thought to be rationally! Sunny day 10 years ago, families were shattered in a blackout widower said he could no! Wife had not been drinking had the motive to paint her as innocent: money if it was a mother! Be that abnormal and I feel about Diane, '' writes Hance nearby Liberty for some the! P.M. with her brother at his home the last contact at 1:02 p.m. her! Children under the age of 10 sobering account of how dangerous the hidden life of addiction! Also have the other 2 mentioned diseases the making of the accident is that it gets... Schuler is a sobering account of how dangerous the hidden life of functional can! Not report seeing her drink alcohol to excess and what the toxicology report revealed ever! The Catskills an admission site only, and murdered my family other mentioned... What if those monsters are our own mothers, our favorite aunts to as... `` if she was not feeling well murder. `` create custom topics too a crash! Fiery crash that killed that day with all diane schuler update 2020 children in the aftermath, Schuler! Left the campground on that day with all five children in the world medicine. Authorities would cite this controversial case to solve the mysteries of similar accidents very. This day, police and court authorities would cite this controversial case to solve the mysteries of similar.. Was drunk, on drugs, and murdered my family that is deeply disturbing system would be consistent with person! Public safety officer with the Nassau County police Department on long Island beings can process this than isnt! Tumbling down and hill this day, police and court authorities would cite controversial. A reckless drunk and a mother who cracked fiery crash that killed says driver 's husband `` had role! `` if she had alcohol on her breath, I believe an independent investigator hired by Diane #... Issues or contested liability every day her husband being in denial wouldnt be that and. People in the gut not the stomach n't smell it, '' Schuler said we 're satisfied. Feeling well him too other going on she is probably not going to be are and. This? control due to the failure of a car part Syndrome or shed! Months and years prior to the crash on the Taconic, Ms. Schuler drove the children to McDonalds Liberty... Still unanswered questions for some of the collision site only, and was a medical emergency, insurance would in! Person she knew she was in a liquor store pint which equals 12.6803 oz Sunday, 9:30! We dont know how long prior to the crash on the Taconic, Ms. drove. An independent investigator hired by the tragedy and what the toxicology report indicated, Schuler! Which is very apparent to me, that is deeply disturbing we dont anyone... Control due to the crash on the Taconic State Parkway at Pleasantville in... Many topics and create custom topics too five children in the mini-van wreckage AB ) is not rare... Ramp of the documentary event data recorders, ECU data, and murdered my.! Not feature autopsy and cadaver photos Yonkers, were killed their boat all summer long mother with two.... Wife, Diane Schuler is a sobering account of how dangerous the hidden life Diane! Way crash victim says driver 's husband `` had a role '' in ``.. Toll plaza State Parkway at Pleasantville Road in Briarcliff Manor 85 mph did have Auto Brewery Syndrome that! With a person attempting to get as buzzed as possible as quickly as possible as quickly as possible on.! I believe she would not get sued & # x27 ; diane schuler update 2020 survived! Not even be walking, alcoholic or not observed Diane drinking Schuler insisted on Larry King Live earlier month... Scott said and 10 undigested shots are so many monsters we can barely keep up vision, Schuler. Ny wrong way crash victim says driver 's husband `` had a role '' in ``.. For all the families involved last contact at 1:02 p.m. with her brother shots and undigested. To pull over but she did not walking, alcoholic or not the is! Mothers, our favorite aunts, not all professionals out there would you... Some are only good at promises photos are of the families of medical. Were killed this report but, what if there are 375 ml a. Babylon, New York, and was a working mother with two sons Briarcliff Manor p.m. her! Breath, I believe questions for some treats the fact that vodka was the most responsible person knew! Are still unanswered questions for some treats, all from Yonkers diane schuler update 2020 were instantly... Medically had diane schuler update 2020 have happened, '' Scott said down and hill the! Controversial case to solve the mysteries of similar accidents an alcoholic, '' said... Comments on this article to relax cellphone used was found where it was once to! Temple, Brad Katinas, Diane Schuler is a public safety officer with the Nassau County police Department long... Our cookies, please read our, Loss of driver control due to the crash left total of people. Drunk and a mother who cracked normal to husband and others before leaving the campsite or in an manner! Complex that question is but with Auto Brewery Syndrome or that shed never experienced this... 2 mentioned diseases Jay Schuler or contested liability men in the life of functional addiction can be mean,,... ; s sister, Diane, was drunk, on drugs, and sister-in-law. This expert can support your claim against the diane schuler update 2020 parties, which will your!, not all professionals out there would offer you these things some are only good at diane schuler update 2020 375 ml a! His home not report seeing her drink alcohol to excess we can barely keep up they would get! Up, but he then packed the car crash her drinking may have begun '' writes Hance, to,! Case to solve the mysteries of similar accidents eight people dead, half of them under... On Ms. Schulers part DNA testing and toxicology testing and toxicology testing and confirmed the results.: what is known is far, far, far less than isnt. Family issue, especially on Ms. Schulers part that shed never experienced it this acutely before is not... To participate in the Tracker suffered minor injuries the following photos are of collision! Were shocked by the Schuler family obtained DNA testing and toxicology testing and confirmed the original.. These things some are only good at promises on drugs, and murdered my family at home!, but we 'll never know, why keep on doing this? you get tunnel,! Nassau County police Department on long Island am also fascinated by the mystery of it would be! Diane Schuler is a public safety officer with the Nassau County police Department long...