As a result of the robbery the gang made off with $5000 in gold. Micah reveals that the plan is to have Arthur cover them from above while Micah and Dutch go to the meeting. RELATED: 10 Red Dead Redemption 2 Memes That Every Player Can Relate To. As mentioned by Dutch, he did not know she had died until an uncle told him. It is during this meeting Colm reveals he didn't even like his brother, angering Dutch. That was one less obstacle for Micah to hurdle later on and would deal a significant blow towards the overall morale in camp (and further isolate Dutch to his influence). RELATED: Red Dead Online: 10 Most Usable Emotes. From there, players can either select a prompt that sends them back to camp or they can ignore the request and continue about their way. And the reason Dutch left him to die is kind of the whole point of the game. Privacy Policy. If Colm knew about the Blackwater money, Colm would have thought he could torture the location out of Dutch and still hand Dutch over for his freedom. If you return to camp and just sit still for a while, Dutch will come up to you and explain what he thought happened. This was likely Dutchs attempt to create some distance between the gang and Pinkertons. freeing john lead to us being wanted dead or alive, and seeing as colm o'driscoll had light security at his hanging we should have been able to free John easily enough. Nice to think about, the last scene at Beaver Hollow, except you have Dutch, Javier, Micah and Bill on one side and you got Arthur, Hosea, John, Lenny and Saun on the other. Tratado de fisiologia Medica (Arthur Clifton Guyton; John E. Hall, Arthur C. Guyton) Frysk Wurdboek: Hnwurdboek Fan'E Fryske Taal ; Mei Dryn Opnommen List Fan Fryske Plaknammen List Fan Fryske Gemeentenammen. The theory proposes that this head injury is what leads to Dutch's downward spiral, possibly inflicting serious brain damage. The go-to source for comic and superhero movie fans. Artur is a playable character from Fire Emblem: The Sacred Stones. I just finished this mission. Traveling the world ofRed Dead II will reveal secretsabout them, but some secrets about Dutch, in particular, will require a little sleuthing. And in Rdr1 John himself says He was the best man he ever knew. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Exactly, Dutch and Micha probably went back to camp to get Hosea, John, Javier, Bill, Lenney, Charles and Shan because they knew that they were most likely going to have to fight potentially dozens of O'Driscolls. You have good points about Micah being in cahoots with Colm, particularly about the sniper position (even though the O'Driscolls were watching beforehand), and I could see Micah ratting out Dutch to anyone who would get him what he wanted. I was going to say you're like a son to me, but you're more than that." When Arthur returns from being captured by Colm, Dutch shows concern over Arthur, yelling for help and helping them pick Arthur up and getting him to bed. Like this is your son you just leave your son to die I was so mad and why didnt Arthur say anything like he was angry but didnt do or said so much, I guess Im just angry but I want some answers, Arthur told John and Charles about it right after, did you miss that? The world of Red Dead Redemption 2 is sprawling with tons of detail, from the way animals interact to the story hints that developer Rockstar Games hides around every corner. It would seem to me he was just a selfish manipulative guy all along, and they just never figured it out until it's too late. Which in the story mean keeping conrolof his gang. Since almost every other mission has the No healing items requirement I would just automatically do the mission over again but since this mission is different its okay to revert to checkpoint. Your horse is tied up just to the east of your weapons cache. He starts seeing the light through the cracks. Any follow up will sooner or later become derivative of its source material should it play things too close. RELATED: RDR2's Horse Realism In Cold Weather Goes Deeper Than Players Thought By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. One of Dutchs most endearing qualities is just how much he seems to care about education. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Aiden O'Malley inGrand Theft Auto IV is a character the player must break out of prison and kill. good for you tbh, hardest thing in the game is to get a chubby arthur. Although he seemed not realizing that Arthur had always talked to Dutch right after whatever they were planning to do before heading off on his own. A small detail that many Red Dead Redemption 2 players likely missed shows that Dutch genuinely cares about Arthur Morgan's well-being. This caused a feud, which explains why the Van der Linde gang and O'Driscoll gang are constantly fighting. And why? It goes on to say that there is a gang of criminals believed to be under the outlaw of Dutch Van Der Linde, who escaped with approximately a hundred and fifty thousand dollars after a bloody gunfight with Pinkerton agents in Blackwater the day before. I can proove it. Arthur's stepmother Emma Tustin, 32, has been jailed for life for his murder, and will serve a minimum term of 29 years. When they became sick, or questioned him, they weren't useful anymore. Even if he couldnt capture everyone he had to kill them all to be safe. Dutch mentions what happened after. I mean every armed member of the van der Linde Gang was a capable fighter, and even leaving one man like Bill, Javier, John or worst (for Colm) Charles could mean his death one day. Naturally, because of his increased screen-time, you learn a lot more about the charismatic gang leader. kill Colm after he killed Annabel (who I think Dutch was just in love with the idea of being in love with), but he did kill him after he kidnapped and tortured his boy Arthur. Crazy. This changed when Colm killed Annabelle, a womanthat Dutch was in love with. It is genuinely worth discussing as even Hoseas name can be seen in the ledger, and often at that. Blessed are the Peacemakersis unlocked after completing The Fine Joys of Tobacco. After the sniper is removed, Arthur takes up position on the roof with his sniper rifle, while Dutch and Sadie each hold an O'Driscoll hostage at gunpoint. They didn't go looking for you because you were handed over as part of the agreement. Image credit: Rockstar Studios/Red Dead Redemption 2 (Youtube/MrBossFTW) Watch Dutch and Micah through the binoculars, and wait for the meeting. Both of us -- They offered me a price, Dutch, to bring you in." From gaming trends to the latest blockbuster anime, DualShockers keeps you ahead of the curve. Arthur says he tried to ride The Count, but was bucked off very quickly. Although the game never gets into what exactly happened in Blackwater - mostly because neither John or Arthur were actually present for the ordeal - you can piece together the main beats thanks to a mix of Arthurs journal and Dutchs true nature. It'd been so terribly long. tl;dr I don't think Colm ever intended to kill Dutch because he and Micah were already planning to hand him over to the Pinkertons in exchange for their own freedom. Where are they? Arthur is knocked unconscious a few times until he finally has an opportunity to escape. Brian Winters is a video game fan from Ocean Springs, Mississippi. Maybe the stress of not keeping a gang together allowed Dutch's hair to return to its natural color. Concerned for her safety, he tells her to remain at the village while he heads out to assist the travelers who had just came in. "Oh, Arthur, don't worry too much," Colm said, leaning in close. But Arthur went behind his back to get John out, because Dutch didn't explain this to anyone so that the rat couldn't know what he was trying to do. Blessed are the Peacemakers is the 39th main story mission in Red Dead Redemption 2 (RDR2).This walkthrough will guide you through all objectives ofBlessed are the Peacemakers Main Quest including all Gold Medals for 100%completion. NEXT: Games To Play If You Loved Red Dead Redemption 2. Same as this one. Hell, New Austin was supposed to be used for something with Arthur. "It was Bizare, we just kept talking then Colm and his men just sort of took off, we waited around and thought we were going to get ambushed but nothing happened, then we went to meet up with you where we said we would and when you didn't show up Micha and I knew something was wrong". Micah was practically serving Colm his greatest enemy's head on a silver platter. And as Arthur does note in his journal after hes recovered that Dutch made many guilt laden apologies so in the moment he probably just couldnt bare to see Arthur like that. As soon as Arthur was about to grab his gun, Dutch steps on his hand to avoid shooting Micah because Dutch believed that Micah was the only loyal gang member left. His favorite author is seemingly Evelyn Miller. Arthur tries one more time to plead to Dutch that Micah is the rat, but Dutch instead just walks away. After this, Colm leaves. Arthur, along with every other member of the gang, was a means to an end for Dutch, and when Dutch could no longer count on Arthur to be his loyal dog, all that loyalty shit went out the window. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Guns are gone and not at the camp after the mission how do I get them back with my gang? Arthur Morgan. Cant find my replaced weapons after quest. It was? November 2, 2018 by Jack McBastard 9 Comments. RELATED: The Best Open-World Games On Steam. "We are going after the others, we are going to eat those inbred lords out of their castles, and we are going to be the Robin Hoods this world so badly needs." . "Why didn't you take it." The bigger question is why did Arthur not make bigger deal about that? Personally I think he just lost his mind and himself because there is a clear time when he would gladly sacrifice himself however of course it annoys me a bit how Dutchs got Arthur to do everything dangerous like that monster crocodile thing, Well they probably didn't know where Arthur was kept. Anyone who has playedGrand Theft Auto IV might recognize this as the name of a certain character. Saint Denis prime rib n all the venison on the way me boy. His peripheral vision is too good to try for a stealth kill. Why would you plan to capture a sniper position then plan to keep it from yourself and the person who thought they had the upper hand with it? Arthur Morgan is a central character and the primary protagonist of Red Dead Redemption 2. I couldn't even get him up from critically underweight to just normal underweight. Both characters did not have a family and were committing crimes before being saved by Dutch. He meets Eirika and . This was likely Dutch's attempt to create some distance between the gang and Pinkertons. They were just like nothing happened? The go-to source for comic and superhero movies. All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. One element that Red Dead Redemption 2 players might not have picked up on is Dutch's genuine concern for Arthur Morgan anytime he ventures from camp for too long. After all, Arthur was raised by Dutch and Hosea for nearly twenty years. Colm's reason for kidnapping Arthur is to lure Dutch into a rescue attempt that will result in the whole Van der Linde Gang being captured by lawmen. I think Dutch never really cared for anyone. It would be great if DLC was Arthur in New Austin before everything went pear-shaped in Blackwater. Both missions feature Dutch making a speech about his inability to fight nature. Where the former sees him using it as a boast, the latter shows a sincerity a genuine belief that he cannot live amongst the natural world any longer. still dont feel like Micah is gonna kill Arthur, sure they have had their ups and downs and Micah is a bit shooting happy but to kill Arthur? I agree Colm is playing games with Dutch, he's jealous and wants to hurt Dutch, but kidnapping Arthur wouldn't demoralise the gang because it would only give Dutch a reason to rally them like the charismatic leader he is. Considering the text, its quite obvious this is Dutchs mother, buried where it all began. But, to answer the question with the writing we got, Colm would have known Arthur had been successfully captured when the meeting concluded and an angry Arthur didn't put a bullet in his head. But, to run with your theory of Micah the rat, Micah and Colm wouldn't have trusted each other. The charismatic leader even gets into a debate with Lenny about Miller's books as the young man isn't as big of a fan. However, if you put any thought into the circumstances of the kidnapping, it quickly makes no sense at all. So why let Dutch leave? A lot of players dont want to believe that Dutch was always a piece of shit, and that he only went crazy with the stressful events of the game, but as both Arthur and John recognize, He just started becoming more of who he really was., He may of said something but his reaction wasnt very big is probably what they mean Im a bit annoyed he didnt have an argument with Dutch over it. At this point an ODriscoll will come down to check on you, and you will automatically go into cover near the door. He doesnt even seem that happy when he sees him come back, or worried because he is shot and barely standing. Chapter: 3 Sadly, it is during one of these heists that Hosea is killed and the gang realizes Dutch is going mad. Keep in mind it's really cold outside, and he doesn't look like he's dressed for the weather. His favorite video game series are 'Half-Life', 'Fallout' and 'Metro'. It goes to show that Dutch doesnt really care about his family. I don't think it's that Colm saw Arthur kidnapped and rescued before, but that he knows Arthur is Dutch's right-hand man/main source of muscle for the gang and that he's practically a son to Dutch. Youll wake up safe and sound back in camp, and the mission will be over. Would that have meant Micah wouldn't have been able to get the location of Dutch's stash? He is the literal face and name of the gang so he represents it. Just on my second play through (on PC this time), Micah is horrible, but Dutch is the worst, I wanted to just shoot him, time and time again. As the two traveled, they picked up more and more members to grow the size of the gang. and our Turn the left stick until the icon goes white, then do the same with the right stick. Dutch appears torn on what to do. Required fields are marked *. A lot of Dutch's past is known to the player and the gang, but some parts of his past must be discovered by exploring and talking to other characters. You will see a gun icon on your minimap to show you where Arthurs weapons are. As for why he didn't snipe Dutch there and then, well, Colm is an egomaniac and probably wants to see Dutch show up and grovel for a few hours before turning him in alive for the brownie points. Its kind of weird how Dutch just went back to camp instead of trying to meet up with Arthur. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Dutch's horse is named The Count and is a white Arabian. if they did go to save Arthur they definitely would have been set up to arrive to Pinkertons. Dutch is a charismatic outlaw with a penchant for leadership and his betrayal of protagonist Arthur Morgan, as well as John Marston, has made him a marked man so to speak. There is a random camp encounter just after the mission with Dutch that I have only got in 1 of the 3 playthroughs I have done. Dutch is only interested in money as an intermediate solution to his main objective - power. Cookie Notice They lied to us, as Arthur has a very terrible aim. As soon as one went, the other one, and the outlaw gang life they lived, wouldn't be far behind. As a child, his mother died of unknown causes, while his father was a petty criminal and outlaw. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. That's why he was so sure of Dutch's response. When he gets home, Dutch was saying "What, what happened". As a lover of literature, Dutch passes on his skills onto his followers. idk still not feeling it. \ 25 FEB-3 MARCH 2023 More adventures in \ } i " Back for the final series the Star Wars galaxy SRY. This makes the end ofRed Dead Redemption II a little sadder, as the gang falls apart and people's opinion of Dutch shifts. Can you go into any further detail? Dutch can also be heard making fun of the southerners found throughout Lemoyne. Filed Under: Game Guides, Red Dead Redemption 2. Considering how well known his gang is and the fact that the Pinkertons are hot on their trail starting with Chapter two. Because he witnessed it before. 105. then in rd1 for john to kill javier and bill? It is kinda suspicious in that Micah certainly knew where the house was so it could allude to come kind of collusion, but, equally, the O'Driscolls were in the area for quite some time and so could have found the house on their own. Dutch talks about the writer and his work on several occasions. How could he be so sure? Its weird they didnt look for him immediately when he didnt show. Dutchs name seldom, if ever, actually appears. Did Micah even think Dutch would do that? Bessie Matthews - The wife of Hosea Matthews, Bessie died prior to the events of Red Dead Redemption 2 . He goes to The University of Southern Mississippi and works for the school paper. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. TL;DR Dutch is an asshole. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Arthur and Dutch are both accomplished shooters (especially Dutch, considering how he managed to hit John in the binoculars from a long distance and with a pistol, in RDR 1), they could have sniped Colm from that distance. By that point in the story, Arthur was very blatantly outspoken against Dutch's plans. Thats the same case with Lenny too, actually. During the initial exchange he tells Dutch that: "Lot of heat on us this time. She's played video games for at least as long as she could write, and vice versa! At least, thats the way I see it. Its interesting that he has the opportunity to shoot Micah at the end of "Redemption" but doesn't. They seemed on good terms right up until the end of Chapter 3 and the start of 4. It goes to show that Dutch doesn't really care about his "family". Well, what made Micah think the Colm-Arthur abduction plan would have gotten that anyway? Any signal could have alarmed Dutch, and an alarmed and cornered Dutch was probably very dangerous( as seen in RDR 1). They terrorized the West until 1899 when a botched train robbery occurs, and several gang members leave Arthur and John to die. While at camp, you may notice that Dutch spends plenty of time reading books. It seems the intense loyalty that the leader inspires in people works on animals, too. Arthur's fading screams - little more than rasps at this point - were starting to grate on his nerves worse than ever, his throat worn raw from days of being the O'Driscoll's punching bag. Dutch is the real villain and he spans 2 games, pretty impressive bad guy. As soon as he has the sniper position, he has Dutch. You will automatically reach up and free your feet, dropping to the ground. As you start to go up the stairs, you will automatically stop as two ODriscoll guards pass the doorway above you going in opposite directions. As the leader of the gang, it has to be brought into question: should Dutch donate as well? Covering the hottest movie and TV topics that fans want. With Arthur and John having their doubts about Dutch's real plan, they begin wondering if Dutch had lost his sanity. Despite seeing Arthur being circled by a small group of soldiers, Dutch simply abandons Arthur and leaves him to die. Wrong, the hardest thing is to keep him at perfect weight. Ride out to the meeting with Dutch and Micah. When the gang falls apart, Susan is killed by Micah. (Thanks to user Yukino for the tip!). To this day, RDR players are sharing discoveries from their time looking at all of the characters in the camp, and how those relationships influence the events of the game. I don't think it's too weird. Maybe it was his idea to abduct Arthur as well. Her partner . He wanted to beat Dutch, to prove he was the better leader, the better man. im happy that dutch arthur and sadie got to share in making sure colm o'driscoll ate shit bc as much as i hate dutch i took what colm did to arthur so fucking personally Dutch is pretty much defenseless: there's him, Micah and Arthur and Micah is a turncoat that sold Arthur out. However, I don't think Colm wanted to kill Dutch either. Well, we only know that Dutch, Hosea and Arthur had large bounties on them. Colm comes to gloat over Arthur; he explains that the parley was merely a ruse to capture Arthur so that Dutch would attempt to rescue him. Also, Arthur had been trying to advise Dutch a lot throughout the game, and Dutch probably blames Arthurs advice even if he never followed it, its honestly adorable you think Dutch actually took any of Arthur and Hoseas advice. We dont see what happens at the meet up after Arthur fades to black. Arthur was 14 and John was 12 when they joined the gang. But by the end of "Redemption" he can probably see it is already beyond repair. stop caring about Arthur? By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Arthur is becoming a problem for Dutch as this point and he has Micah in his ear. Hoseas demise right before Guarma, with everything else going on at that point, he just became a paranoid, crazed man. Same reason why Molly never does any work, since she's 'his' she's better than everyone else, because Dutch thinks he is better than everyone else. I mean surely they would meet Arthur after that meeting with Colm, yet Micah and Dutch didn't say what happened with Colm at all? Red Dead Redemption 2: 10 Things You Didn't Know About Dutch, Dutch Formed The Gang With Hosea After Trying To Rob Each Other, 10 Awesome Secret Missions In Red Dead Redemption 2 You Need To Try, 10 Red Dead Redemption 2 Memes That Every Player Can Relate To, Red Dead Redemption 2: The 10 Most Craziest Random Encounters You Probably Missed, Red Dead Online: 10 Collector Tips Everyone Should Know. Also, I dont think youre captured for that long, less than 2 full days if not only 12 hours or so. Dutch and Micah want to keep riding with their money, but Arthur and Sadie go to save Abigail, refusing to let Jack grow up as an orphan. Arthur answered your question himself. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Its not as happy go lucky, hes reserved and questioning. When you come to, youll be hanging on chains by your feet. When you dig your fingers into someone's wound, generally they're going to scream. If you let him go, he'll run away. Colm told Arthur that he wanted to set a trap so that Dutch and the gang would be caught and he could then bargain with the law, the Van der Linde gang for his gangs freedom. Hosea tried to con Dutch, but Dutch was doing the same thing and had actually stolen from him. Arguably Red Dead Redemption 2s greatest strength as a sequel is its ability to comment on the cyclical nature of narrative. He basically dominated Arthurs life for two decades because of this. One thing is that Dutch probably didnt know that Arthur was captured. Yeah, I could get behind this, and now I know I should read the journal more. And now Hosea was dead and they were stranded on a boat to the other side of the world and Dutch was still just as beautiful as he'd been twenty years ago. Swing to the left and right using the left stick until youre in range to grab the file. Colm ODriscoll himself will come to interrogate you for a bit before you pass out again. "Isaac. Dutch and Colm acted as partners for a time, however, it appeared the two began drifting apart when Dutch founded his own gang after meeting Hosea Matthews, as it put Hosea and Colm in direct competition with each other. He also did then when kidnapped by colm in chapped 3 they werent planning to save him. They were waiting til first light to try and follow your tracks. Maybe this will help someone but I found while replaying the mission (not sure about main playthrough since itll be hard to judge if you got ~1 minute or not), after you perform the surgery on yourself and have to kill the four enemies, is that even if you get caught you can just restart from the checkpoint so you wont have to do the entire thing over again. It's also possible that they just hadn't arranged a search party yet. Dutch is not a particularly familial person, in spite of the show he puts on for his gang mates. I like to think that everyone that died up until then would have chosen Arthurs side (Hosea, Lenny and Saun). He only assumed Arthur just got up and left to do whatever he felt like as he always seemed to be away to keep the provisions and supplies of the gang afloat. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. They got back from the meetup, realized you weren't there, but it was already too dark to send out a search party. The lawmen don't recognise any of the gang members except these three and the O'Driscolls only ever recognise Arthur in the shootouts. It'd been so long. and our Why is this? Nederlnsk - Frysk (Visser W.) K. (Bernardo Kucinski) cc din kinh t th gii (v i lc) Le serie sono serie. He mentions his father, but seldom his mother. TheGamer is the leading source for video game news, reviews, topical features, and deep-dive interviews, delivered right through your eyeballs and into your brain box. This killing came in retaliation after Dutch killed Colm's brother. This is one of the rarer horses in the game. Go ahead and saddle up and follow Eagle Flies and the group. If the O'Driscoll's killed Arthur in the process, great! I didnt recover the weapons on the missions and now i cant find them in the canp too. It isnt a particularly flattering picture. Every family has problems, but these problems become very big towards the end ofRed Dead Redemption II. Arthur reveals that he tried to mount the horse once but was immediately bucked off. If players do spend too much time away from the Red Dead Redemption 2 camp, Dutch will send out a member of the group to find Arthur Morgan and bring him back. When Micah indicates, head up the hill following the path to the waypoint. Please tell me Im missing something. American stage actor, director, playwright, screenwriter and producer [1] Rosa Albach-Retty. Yes. While he does preach about family, and it is implied he does genuinely see themselves as a family, he rarely, if ever, divulges any personal information.